Remarque : Le contenu ci-dessous est en anglais original. La traduction est en cours.
In the heavyweight championship of AI Image Generators, Midjourney has held the belt for a long time due to its stunning aesthetic quality. But Whisk AI (by Google Labs) is entering the ring with a different strategy: Control.
Which one is right for you? Let's break it down.
.jpg)
Feature Comparison Matrix
| Feature | Midjourney | Whisk AI |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Interface | Discord / Web Alpha | Dedicated Visual App |
| Input Type | Text + Image Prompts | Subject / Scene / Style |
| Learning Curve | High (Prompt Syntax) | Low (Visual Drag-Drop) |
| Composition Control | Low (Randomized) | High (Scene Reference) |
| Consistency | Moderate (--cref) | High (Identity Lock) |
| Aesthetic Quality | Excellent (Stylized) | Varies (Dependent on input) |
1. Ease of Use
- Midjourney: Requires Discord (for now) or a web alpha. Heavily reliant on "prompt engineering"—knowing terms like
--ar 16:9,--v 6.0,--stylize. - Whisk AI: Visual interface. Drag and drop. No code-like syntax.
- Winner: Whisk AI for beginners; Tie for pros.
2. Control Over Composition
- Midjourney: You can use Image Prompts, but the AI often takes liberties. Getting a character on the left vs the right can be a struggle of re-rolling.
- Whisk AI: Explicit "Scene" input. If your scene image has a chair on the left, Whisk puts the subject on the left.
- Winner: Whisk AI.
.jpg)
3. Aesthetic "Vibes"
- Midjourney: Famous for its "Midjourney Look"—highly artistic, dramatic lighting, often better than reality.
- Whisk AI: As a style transfer engine, it is more neutral. It creates what you tell it to. It relies on you providing a good Style reference.
- Winner: Midjourney (for out-of-the-box beauty).
The Verdict
Choose Midjourney If:
- You want the absolute highest fidelity "art" with minimal effort.
- You are brainstorming and want the AI to surprise you.
- You enjoy the community aspect of Discord.
Choose Whisk AI If:
- You are a professional designer needing specific compositions.
- You have specific assets (product, character) you need to incorporate.
- You struggle with writing complex text prompts.
- You need strict brand consistency.
Ultimately, they are complementary tools. Many pros use Midjourney to generate the components (Subject, Scene, Style) and then use Whisk AI to combine them into the final shot.
